kcw | reviews | dvd << Previous Page | Next Page >>
Year:   2000
Studio: Warner Brothers/Village Roadshow Pictures
Movie:  3/5
DVD:    1/5


Both Red Planet and Mission to Mars came out in the same year. Mission to Mars came out first and I thought it was a bit lacking. Great special effects and a nice looking movie, but I thought the ending was rushed and too pat. Red Planet has many similarities to the other movie. Both have small crews in gigantic space ships. Both have natural disasters which force the crew to abandon their space ship and crash land on Mars with practically nothing. Other than those superficial similarities, the movies are remarkably different.

Earth is dying, not anytime soon but definitely within the next two or three generations. Mars is a nearby planet that would require comparatively little terraforming. So Earth sends various remote rockets to Mars, packed with nuclear bombs to free up ice into water and an atmosphere and algae to transform carbon dioxide to oxygen. It went well for a while but then the algae disappeared.

The year is 2047. A crew of six are going to Mars to find out what went wrong. Making up the crew is Commander Kate Bowman (Carrie-Anne Moss), and Lieutenant Ted Santen (Benjamin Bratt) handling the piloting duties. Dr Bud Chantilas (Terence Stamp), Chip Pettengill (Simon Baker) and Dr Quinn Burchenal (Tom Sizemore) are the mission specialists. Rounding out the crew is Robby Gallagher (Val Kilmer), the only technician. Another "member" of the crew is AMEE the robot, a tiger-like Marine combat robot converted into a scouting role.
After six months the ship arrives at Mars and disaster strikes. A massive solar flare cripples their ship. Everybody has to leave now, but Commander Bowman has to stay behind to launch the lander. The lander crashes, Dr Chantilas is mortally wounded, and AMEE is damaged enough to revert to her combat mode. Meanwhile Bowman is dealing with the fires and other damage on the ship.

What remains of the ground crew has the big mystery to solve while a killer robot stalks them. What I like about the movie is that the questions about Mars are solved without resorting to aliens. It's an interesting mechanic having Commander Bowman up there while the guys are down there. There is a romance subplot between Bowman and Gallagher, but it sort of springs full-blown without warning because the "falling in love" scenes aren't there.

The DVD has some deleted scenes but that's it.

What I like: it's a grittier science fiction movie than Mission to Mars. The story is more action oriented and the questions have believable (to me) answers.

What I didn't like: The romance subplot wasn't developed enough. Either do it more or cut it all out. The whole "Carrie-Ann Moss resuscitates the male lead" ending was too Matrix-like for me.

Copyright (c) 2004 Kevin C. Wong
Page Created: August 1, 2004
Page Last Updated: August 1, 2004